”White imperialism" and epistēmē or Foucault ‘abused boys in Tunisia’ (2)
I have written my own comments on the Nikkei Business website article and our blog article. I would appreciate it if you could refer to them.
(1) Our comments on the Nikkei Business article (2021/04/14)
Pedophilia and white imperialist suspicions about Foucault, a giant of 20th century knowledge: Nikkei Business e-Bulletin
White imperialism is latent in Western intellectuals, hard to extract. Kant, an advocate of black slavery, went so far as to say that the best thing for blacks was to civilize them, and that was to make them work for whites (this was taken from Marx Gabriel).
Compared to the contemporaneous French neighbors who created the "Friends of Negroes", Kant is somewhat less coherent (=double standard) as a great teacher of ethics. My judgment is that it is better for us non-Westerners to keep it in mind and decide individually whether to "use" or "discard.
(2) Self-comment on our blog post (2021/04/15)
White imperialism" and episteme: Hon ni Oboretai
I would like to add.
In the comment section of (2) above, there are a number of posts "defending" Foucault. I can only assume that these people have a fatal lack of imagination.
If they have a daughter/son around 10 years old, how would they feel if Foucault said to them, "It's okay to have intercourse with your child if it's consensual. Right?"
There is no way I could allow such a thing. You would think that such a person should be thrown into jail as soon as possible, or be sentenced to "punishment by exile" as in the Tokugawa period.
At the very least, it is outside the scope of "human freedom" when it comes to sexual activity between adults and minors (under the adult provision that legally entrenched social conventions).
This resentment is something different from the discourse that Foucault has been working on, I should think, but from a "emotional" point of view, it must be quite difficult. This is my honest opinion.
See (1).
(The above was translated with the help of DeepL.)
| 固定リンク
« ”White imperialism" and epistēmē or Foucault ‘abused boys in Tunisia’ (1) | トップページ | A human being is born as a "daughter" or "son" »
「Weber, Max」カテゴリの記事
- Seki Hirono, Unearthing the Forgotten History of Ideas, 1985(2024.07.14)
- 関 曠野「忘れられた思想史の発掘」1985年11月(2024.07.13)
- Two Europe(2022.12.22)
- 価格を決定するものは、「需要」ではなく、「費用」である(2)/ What determines price is not "demand" but "cost" (2)(2022.12.17)
- The future as an imitation of the Paradise(2022.10.30)
「Kant, Immanuel」カテゴリの記事
- It is difficult to imagine that anyone would be able to improve on this volume in the foreseeable future.(2024.02.20)
- 徳川思想史と「心」を巡る幾つかの備忘録(3)/Some Remarks on the History of Tokugawa Thought and the "mind"(kokoro「こころ」)(2023.06.11)
- 徳川日本のニュートニアン/ a Newtonian in Tokugawa Japan(2023.05.18)
- Wataru Kuroda's "Epistemology"(2023.05.01)
- 黒田亘の「認識論」(2023.04.30)
「本居宣長(Motoori, Norinaga)」カテゴリの記事
- ”White imperialism" and epistēmē or Foucault ‘abused boys in Tunisia’ (2)(2021.04.18)
- ”White imperialism" and epistēmē or Foucault ‘abused boys in Tunisia’ (1)(2021.04.13)
- 「白い帝国主義」と epistēmē(2021.04.13)
- 「悪」の存在確率/probability of evil(2020.05.04)
- 江戸人の「本居信仰」(1)(2019.05.26)
「社会科学方法論 / Methodology of Social Sciences」カテゴリの記事
- 20世紀におけるドイツ「概念史」とアメリカ「観念史」の思想史的比較 / A historical comparison of the German “Begriffsgeschichte” and American “History of Ideas”of the 20th century(2024.11.19)
- 柳田国男「實驗の史學」昭和十年十二月、日本民俗學研究/ Yanagida Kunio, Experimental historiography, 1935(2024.10.20)
- リア・グリーンフェルド『ナショナリズム入門』2023年11月慶應義塾大学出版会/訳:小坂恵理,解説:張 彧暋〔書評①〕(2024.09.16)
- 塩沢由典『複雑さの帰結』1997年、の「解題集」(2024.08.13)
- Rose petals in the canyon(2023.10.25)
「荻生徂徠(Ogyu, Sorai)」カテゴリの記事
- 徂徠における規範と自我 対談 尾藤正英×日野龍夫(1974年11月8日)/Norms and Ego in the Thought of Ogyu Sorai [荻生徂徠](2023.08.30)
- 自由と尊厳を持つのは、よく笑い、よく泣く者のことである(2)/ Freiheit und Würde haben diejenigen, die oft lachen und oft weinen (2)(2023.06.06)
- 徂徠、カーライル、そしてニーチェ/ Ogyu Sorai, Carlyle, & Nietzsche(2023.01.04)
- 尾藤正英著『日本の国家主義 「国体」思想の形成』2020年岩波書店(オンデマンド版pbk)(2022.11.28)
- ”White imperialism" and epistēmē or Foucault ‘abused boys in Tunisia’ (2)(2021.04.18)
「Foucault, Michel」カテゴリの記事
- Proof of Origin for "Modernity"(2022.12.25)
- 「Modernity」の原産地証明(2022.12.25)
- ライア・グリーンフェルド(Liah Greenfeld)"ナショナリズム三部作”(2022.04.28)
- Liah Greenfeld's "Trilogy of Nationalism"(2022.04.28)
- What Foucault accomplished(2021.04.19)
コメント