Confucius and Michael Polanyi
Does "communicating" mean "getting the message across"? Being in the education industry, I always wonder about this. Michael Polanyi, a philosopher of science, says,
The possibility of teaching … is that we can do so only by relying on the pupil's intelligent co-operation for catching the meaning of the demonstrarion. (p.5)
Our message had left something behind that we could not tell, and its reception must rely on it that the person addressed will discover that which we have not been able to communicate. (p.6)
Michael Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension, 1983, Peter Smith (Reprint of 1966)
This concern has been mentioned by Confucius for over two thousand years.
論語 (國譯漢文大成)/衞靈公第十五之十五
子曰:「不曰『如之何,如之何』者,吾末如之何也已矣」
〈子曰く、之を如何せむ、之を如何せむと曰はざる者は、吾之を如何にともするなきのみ。〉
論語 (國譯漢文大成)/衞靈公第十五 - Wikisource
I agree with them that the student's willingness to learn is very important. However, the other person is also an independent human being. We can't force them to change from "being forced to learn" to "wanting to learn. I am repeating the process of trial and error.
| 固定リンク
「言葉/言語 (words / languages)」カテゴリの記事
- 英語の三単現(三人称単数現在)の謎を解く(2025.02.25)
- Language as an Interface 〔Revised on 20250302〕(2025.01.20)
- 20世紀におけるドイツ「概念史」とアメリカ「観念史」の思想史的比較 / A historical comparison of the German “Begriffsgeschichte” and American “History of Ideas”of the 20th century(2024.11.19)
- Words, apophatikē theologia, and “Evolution”(2024.08.26)
- 変わることと変えること/ To change oneself, or to change someone(2024.02.16)
「科学哲学/科学史(philosophy of science)」カテゴリの記事
- ラプラスの悪魔 / Laplacescher Geist / démon de Laplace (2)(2025.05.05)
- Isaiah Berlin’s Philosophy of History and My Position (2020.4.13)(2025.05.02)
- Bricolage and theory of resources(2025.04.16)
- Language as an Interface 〔Revised on 20250302〕(2025.01.20)
- 現代数学におけるお国柄(仏・独・英・露・米・日)/ The national character of modern mathematics (France, Germany, England, Russia, America, Japan)(2025.01.13)
「学習理論(learning theory)」カテゴリの記事
- Communication Between Honne (an ulterior motive) and Tatemae (principles)(2025.05.04)
- 愚かな勉強法と賢い勉強法/ Stupid, or Smart Study Methods(2024.04.22)
- Failure is a part of learning / 失敗は学びの一部である(2022.11.12)
- 心の扉の開き方/ How to open the door to the heart(2022.05.05)
- The Body as Empirical Rationalist(2022.04.25)
「mimēsis (ミメーシス)」カテゴリの記事
- Bricolage and theory of resources(2025.04.16)
- Does the Imperial Anthology of Poetry exist in Europe?(2025.02.28)
- 日中の文化資源における女性比率の差異/中日文化资源中女性比例的差异/Differences in the Ratio of Women in Cultural Resources between Japan and China(2025.02.27)
- 関 曠野「知は遅れて到来する ―ドラマにおける時間について―」(1985年5月)/Seki Hirono, Knowledge Comes Late, On Time in Drama, 1985(2024.07.20)
- LILIUM: ラテン語によるアニソン/ LILIUM: The anime song written in Latin (2)(2023.11.28)
コメント