The core of liberalism lies not in freedom, but in justice
Freedom matures only when it is subject to the discipline of publicness imposed by the concept of justice—when it transforms from "freedom from others," that is, a self-empowering liberty driven by a desire to dominate, assimilate, or exclude others if domination fails, into "freedom toward others," that is, a liberty that welcomes critique and disruptive influences from others as catalysts for self-transformation that expands and reorganizes one's own mental horizon. The freedom recognized by liberalism is not "freedom from others" as a capacity prior to justice, but rather "freedom toward others," which is made possible by justice. In this sense, to say that the foundational principle of liberalism is not freedom but justice means exactly this.
—Tatsuo Inoue, “Why Question Liberalism? — Preface to the Korean Edition of Freedom Toward the Other,” Soubun No. 519 (May 2009), p. 6.
Hmm, quite difficult. I feel it means something like this: the freedom of mutual criticism is an opportunity for each person's human development, and such mutual interference through criticism is permissible only when each individual abides by the discipline of publicness called justice. Well then, let’s just say — I’ll try again another day.
※This article is an English translation of the following blog post.
リベラリズムの核心は、自由ではなく正義である
| 固定リンク
« Über den Hass | トップページ | Der Kern des Liberalismus ist nicht die Freiheit, sondern die Gerechtigkeit »
「書評・紹介(book review)」カテゴリの記事
- 石川 淳「江戸人の発想法について」昭和18年3月/ Jun Ishikawa, “On the Way of Thinking of the People of Edo,” March 1943(2026.04.13)
- From Max Weber to Jacques Barzun(2026.03.10)
- Max Weber から Jacques Barzun へ(2026.03.09)
- Alfred W. Crosby, The Measure of Reality (1997, Cambridge University Press)(2025.10.23)
- アルフレッド・W・クロスビー『数量化革命:ヨーロッパ覇権をもたらした世界観の誕生』(小沢千重子訳)、2003年、紀伊国屋書店(2025.10.23)
「法哲学・法理論/jurisprudence Rechtsphilosophie」カテゴリの記事
- Events and Accountability(Tuesday, September 20, 2016)(2026.05.16)
- Pierre Legendre vs. Harold J.Berman [English version](2025.10.20)
- Pierre Legendre contre Harold J. Berman [Version française](2025.10.20)
- ピエール・ルジャンドル 対 ハロルド J. バーマン(2025.10.20)
- Toward a Shift from ”an Orientation to Acquisition and Property” to ”One of Care and Obligation”(2025.07.06)
「 political theory / philosophy(政治哲学・政治理論)」カテゴリの記事
- Pierre Legendre vs. Harold J.Berman [English version](2025.10.20)
- Pierre Legendre contre Harold J. Berman [Version française](2025.10.20)
- ピエール・ルジャンドル 対 ハロルド J. バーマン(2025.10.20)
- Intellectual History of the "Sphere of Intimacy" : before and after Arendt(2025.08.26)
- 「親密圏」アーレント以後とそれ以前(2025.08.26)


コメント